HomeNewsAboutCommunitiesSearchSchoolsInteractGatewayHelp
The New Zealand Curriculum ExemplarsExemplars homepageAssessment homepage
Science exemplars homepage
Science: Living World Level indicator Back to Level 1 Back to Level 2 Back to Level 3 Back to Level 4 Back to Level 5

Developing Interest and Relating Scientific Learning to the Wider World
Thinking in Scientific Ways
Investigating in Science

Is a Tree a Plant?

Teachers' notes
Progress indicators
What the work shows Curriculum links The learning context Where to next

What the work shows

Matthew is able, with guidance, to make observations relevant to the question being investigated. His initial view that trees and plants belong to different scientific groups is one that is commonly held by young students. He changed his view as a result of the teacher providing opportunities for him to investigate a range of ideas.

Matthew's “before” view Matthew's “after” view

Matthew's "before" view

Matthew's "after" view

Matthew examining plants  

Matthew examining plants

 

Progress Indicators

Developing Interest and Relating Scientific Learning to the Wider World

Experiencing and showing awe, wonder, and interest
Matthew told the class that he had heard that "roses eat banana skins". This created much amusement and amazement among the students and, after discussion, they decided that he needed to find out more. After going home and talking to his mother, a gardener, he reported the next day that roses like the potassium in the banana skins and that they get this as the skin rots. In doing this, he showed that he is able to pursue a scientific activity outside the formal learning environment.

Thinking in Scientific Ways

Suggesting explanations
Matthew can offer an explanation for an observation (see "before" view). However, he is unable to justify it as his ideas about plants, based on his previous experiences, are restricted to flower plants (L1).

Comparing and evaluating explanations
Matthew's "after" view drawing is of a tree. It shows a shift in understanding and that with support he can change his ideas in the light of new evidence – he was previously adamant that trees were not plants. His drawing now also includes an interesting root system. Through lots of observations of roots, he became aware that they could be very gnarled and wriggly (L3).

Investigating in Science

Exploring a situation
Matthew makes observations and looks for patterns and relationships as he investigates a variety of plants using magnifying lenses and microscopes (see "before" view). He identifies that:

  • stalks are strong
  • roots can be hairy and differ from plant to plant
  • leaves have lines (veins)
  • leaves sometimes grow out of the stalk.

He and his classmates discussed the function of the parts of a plant and went home to get more ideas (L3).

Processing and interpreting
Matthew is able to reach a conclusion to a simple investigation that is linked to his own knowledge (see "after" view). He answers "yes" to the question and is able to explain that:

  • trees have stalks, but they are called trunks
  • trees have branches, and the leaves grow on them
  • roots hold the plants in the ground.

Print version of this exemplar (PDF, 83kb)

PDF help Printing tip
Non-JavaScript link Non-JavaScript link