HomeNewsAboutCommunitiesSearchSchoolsInteractGatewayHelp
ICT Community News ICT Community News
ICT PD HomeCluster mapKey peopleICT Learning ExperiencesPrivate area
ICT Learning Experience

A Plague on Plagiarism

Purpose
With the increase in inquiry learning activities, and the increased access to a greater variety of information sources such as the Internet and CD-ROMs, we have found that students need to develop good note making skills to enable them to make the most of these advantages.

This same increased digital access though, can lead students to complete assignments by copying and pasting chunks of other people's material into their own work.

The purpose of this experience is to educate students about copyright and plagiarism issues and to improve their research techniques.

Level
Lower secondary, upper primary, upper secondary

Essential learning areas
Language and Languages, Mathematics, Science, Technology, Social Sciences, The Arts, Health and Physical Education, Māori Education

Essential skills
Communication, Information, Problem-solving, Work and Study

Participants
Students and teachers in:

  • year 9 and 10 English classes,
  • year 9 graphics classes, and
  • year 10 social studies classes.

Description
There are two parts to this learning experience. The first, A, requires students to make dot-jot notes and the second part, B, involves students in the skills of thinking, analysing, and synthesising as they work with the information they now have in note form.

Students are given notemaking sheets (pdf, 118k) and are shown examples of the process. Once they have their key questions approved (or their teacher has given them questions), they must find three sources of information for each question. They then make dot-jot notes from each source making sure they complete the reference details at the top of each note section.

A. Making Dot-Jot Notes (pdf, 118k)
Students make a dot and then jot down one point, idea, or fact. They should try to keep to one line per point and they should not use complete sentences. These are notes only. It needs to be emphasised that notes do not need to be perfect – ensure that students do not spend ages writing complete sentences or twinking out mistakes.

This is a useful method to use for summarising the chapter of a book, a poem, or for getting down the main points from a page or chapter. It can be used at any level and in any curriculum area. It is a good idea to practise ahead of time by getting students to make some dot-jot notes from a paragraph of a book they are using.

This exercise is always preceded by a class discussion about copying, copyright, and plagiarism. Students are told that this method will help them avoid plagiarising other people's work.

B. Combining Notes (pdf, 93k)
They then combine these three sets of notes into one set of dot-jot notes using 8 to 10 dots or bullet points. These final points then form the basis for the answer which will be included in the final product – whether it is a speech, report, chart, or some other form of presenting information.

We have found that even if students are answering a simple, background type of question which requires mainly factual material, they need to put in a surprising amount of careful thought and synthesis of information to work out which points from which source to include in the final answer. It is also not at all easy to include copied material when using this method.

Some students dislike the idea of finding several sources, saying that "they have a book with all the information in it" or that they "know it already and don't need to use any resources". This is a good time to point out that it can be helpful to find similar information in different sources as that can be a sign that the information is correct. On the other hand they can often find extra, interesting information that they did not know about and that will add to the quality of their answers.

A blank template (pdf, 118k) is available for anyone wishing to use this technique with their own students.

Evaluation
Students were asked to evaluate the process and all were positive about the experience. They found the dot-jot note making method easy to learn and useful in all subjects. While some complained about having to use more than one source and some found combining the notes difficult at first, they almost all agreed that they felt they had achieved better results, that they liked having such a process to follow and that it would be very useful in the future.

Resources
Dot-Jot notemaking sheets (pdf 118k)
These can be photocopied or student can produce their own from a template on the white or black board.

Author/s
E A Probert eaprobert@internet.co.nz
Cluster
Pakuranga/Farm Cove
Published
January 2002